Franchise Update Story Captures Urban Franchise Development

In the first Franchise Update issue of 2009, I had the honor of being included in Eddy Goldberg’s story: The New ROI: Return on Inclusion, Franchisors Seek Green Pastures in Urban Concrete. In addition to my quotes throughout the article, http://www.franchise-update.com/, I wanted to share with you a few important passages.

Stan Friedman has for the past two years, chairedf the IFA’s MinorityFran program, launched in February 2006 as part of the Diversity Institute’s efforts to 1) build awareness of franchising within minority communities and 2) increase the number of minority franchisees, franchisors, suppliers, and employees.

“Franchisors are missing the boat if they don’t look at those under-served markets as golden opportunities to create revenues for their business, and at the same time serve the community. There’s a compelling case to be made for coming back to inner cities and to under-served consumers,” says Friedman, who helped lead the Urban Expansion Initiative for Blimpie International in 1998 as vice president of global development.

“There still will be challenges, but real estate is less expensive, the pool of people for jobs greater, and federal wage and tax credits and incentives are available,” says Friedman. “All of the sudden your unit economics and startup costs are much better before you even open the door, compared with suburbia.”

Too many times Murphy’s Law intervenes when franchisees are trying to get new locations opened. Be it a permitting problem, a construction delay or the late delivery of some vital piece of equipment, it seems that there’s always something pushing the projected opening date back. Depending on the timelines and financial strength of the franchisee, this can really cause some painful crimps in one’s style and in many cases put the franchisee under water. A much happier pre-opening scenario might look like this: A franchisee’s new unit is under construction within the boundaries of a Federal Empowerment Zone or Renewal Community. He is at the point where he has begun hiring and because most everyone that will work at his store also lives in the neighborhood, the creation of these local jobs makes him eligible for a personal tax credit of up to $3,000 per year, for each qualifying employee he has hired. With 10-12 locals on his payroll, he could be looking at as much as $36,000 in future tax credits.

“Why aren’t franchisors city bound?” Goldberg writes, “Beyond the downside risks most often cited by reluctant franchisors – security and staffing issues – Friedman says, ‘Maybe it’s just something franchisors haven’t spent enough time thinking through.’”

Many franchisors have not even thought about this process because in many cases, it’s too far outside their box. Take this to the bank… no more can franchisors be reactive in their approach to development and depend on yesteryear’s methods of recruiting new blood to their brands. There are some very viable opportunities for inner city development that can put new faces on old neighborhoods, create jobs that are both wanted and needed and serve consumer needs without their need to travel down the line on the bus to find the services they wished were available to them, a bit closer to home.

In terms of social good, says Friedman, franchising in under-served urban markets 1) will change the landscapes of central cities; 2) provide residents with access to needed goods and services; 3) provide residents with access to needed goods and services; 3) create entrepreneurs in the community; and 4) create jobs for people who live there.

“If you’re serious about your commitment, there are resources available through the IFA to help you plot your course and bring your brand into markets that are under-served, and reach out not only to consumers but to potential franchisees as well,” says Friedman. In the past, he says, it might have been more difficult for a franchisor to make a go of it in a diverse inner city market on their own.

Tax credits and incentives should certainly be considered when considering site selection in the inner city. If a proactive approach to candidate selection makes more sense than just reactively speaking to anyone that wants to talk with you, so does the proactive approach to site selection, as well.

MinorityFran, says Friedman, seeks “to create the playbook and glean the best practices” of franchisors succeeding in expanding into cities, and share that intellectual capital with those who want to try it. That involves relationships with many groups nationwide, including SCORE, local banks, La Raza, the National Urban League, and what he calls “an aggressive outreach initiative” through the U.S. Conference of Mayors.

RetroTax is a proud supporter of the IFA MinorityFran initiative and I am proud to be the Immediate Past Chairman of the IFA Minorities in Franchising Committee and First Vice Chair and a founding member of IFA’s Diversity Institute.

Finally, in the article I talked about National Diversity Solutions (NDS), a Lexington, Ky., based company that works with franchisors and large multi-unit franchisees to help them rework the fabric of their supplier channel to reduce costs and introduce diversity. The NDS mission is a no-brainer. Just as MinorityFran has aspired to make the business case for diversity and inclusion, such is so with NDS as well. Their mission is to simplify supply chain diversification and economic inclusion while reducing costs, increasing service levels and promoting a company's commitment throughout the minority community.

At RetroTax we are in the business of identifying and administering wage-based tax credits for businesses that either don’t even know that these economic incentives exist, or who don’t have the time and resources to administer them correctly, even if they did. Additionally, we are looking for franchise affiliations in each of the markets where such credits and incentives exist. What could be better than finding a minority franchisee to service local businesses in his/her local community and build a business serving neighboring businesses, within the community.